Links to stuff on this blog

Use the Site Index of Projects page link above for an easier way to find stuff on my blog that you might be looking for!

Saturday, December 18, 2010

Another Home Made Ranque-Hilsch Vortex Tube

As I mentioned last week I made another Ranque-Hilsch Vortex Cooling Tube that worked better than the last two that I made. If you are interested in the last two HERE and HERE are links to those attempts. In addition to those posts I also made some videos about the construction that you can check out by clicking on the Site Index of Projects link at the top of this blog and scrolling down to the Vortex Cooling Tube links. Below is a thermal image picture I made of the most recent tube in operation.
 
Thermal Image of my Homemade Vortex Cooling Tube

Before I drone on and on about how I built this I'll provide a few links to resources and information on the web about how these work. Like last time HERE is a Wikipedia link to a nice summary about what goes on inside a  Ranque-Hilsch vortex cooling tube. Also HERE is a 500+ page pdf with more information than you probably will ever want to know. Lastly HERE is a link (that is also on the side bar of my blog) to a guy that builds his own cooling tubes. Anyway on to the construction details and results of this experiment.


In case you didn't check out the links above here is a quick summary of what a  Ranque-Hilsch Vortex Cooling Tube does. A fluid (usually a gas) goes into the tube through holes that cause it to spin around the inside wall of the tube like a vortex. The spinning gas moves away from a plate with a hole in it called the Cold Plate Orifice. As it spins away from the Cold Plate Orifice and makes it's way down the tube the hot and cold portions of the gas separate. The hot gas gets hotter and the cold gas gets colder by magic. When the gas reaches the end of the tube the hot part is allowed to leave the tube through a Cone Valve and the cold portion is sent back down the center of the tube where it passes out the Cold Plate Orifice hole. So you put gas of one temperature in and get hotter and colder gas out. Check out THIS Wikipedia link if you have not done so already or at least look at THIS picture I drew just for you!
  
I wanted to build this tube really fast so I kept the design as simple as possible. Surprisingly with this tube I got the best results so far! With an air inlet temperature of 23.4°C (74°F) and about 551kPa (80 psi) of air pressure the best hot end temperature of the tube was 44.8°C (112°F) and the best cold end was -13°C (8.6°F). That is a whopping 57.8°C difference between the hot and cold ends and the cold end was below freezing. An early Christmas miracle maybe?.. read on to find out! Unfortunately I couldn't measure the airflow during the experiment but what I do know is my home garage compressor was not able to get these results because it couldn't keep up the air pressure at the flow rate required by this tube. To get anything to happen I had to take this vortex cooling tube into my work and run it on a industrial sized compressor.
  
Here is an overview diagram of the components used in this tube. It only took me about an hour to build it and as always was made from crap I have lying around my garage (and living room, kitchen etc...). You should be able to click on the picture for a better view.
 
Homemade Ranque-Hilsch Vortex Cooling Tube Construction

Below is a summary of the critical dimensions and performance of this Vortex Tube:
     Tube I.D:                    8.17mm      0.340"
     Cold Plate Orifice:        6.35mm      0.250"
     2 Inlet Jets each:         1.57mm      0.062"
     Length:                       400mm      15.75"
     Inlet Air Pressure:         551kPa      80psi
     Inlet Air Temp:             23.4°C        74°F
     Outlet Hot Temp:          44.8°C      112°F
     Outlet Cold Temp:          -13°C       8.6°F
 
This Vortex Tube used a 1/4" schedule 40 pipe made of PVC that has an I.D. of 0.344". and an O.D. of 0.540". This pipe is considered to be 1/4" even though there is no 1/4" dimension in it and it's made by a company called Harvel, HERE is a link to their site. There is a lot of evidence in the literature that the pipe that you use should be thermally non-conductive or if it is a good conductor (like metal) it should be insulated. I decided to use PVC because I had it laying around and of the three vortex tubes that I have made the metal one didn't work too good. Metal might be the reason for the poor performance.
  
I have read that having more than one inlet jet tends to work better than one so I decided to drill two of them. (The last metal tube that didn't work had one inlet). To get the air into both of the jets I filed a groove around the outside of the 1/4" plastic tube to make a manifold. I chose 0.062 inches for the jets diameter because that was the drill that was left over in the chuck from the last project.
 
Vortex Tube inlet 'manifold groove' and inlet jet hole

In the above picture you can see the groovy manifold and one of the inlet jet holes. There is another inlet jet hole on the other side of the tube. The groove allows air to flow around the tube and enter the jet holes when this end is later inserted in a block. Have a look again at the above construction diagram and read on if this isn't clear yet.
  
To get the air swirling around the inside of the tube (and not just blowing into the center of the tube) the jet holes had to be drilled tangent to the inside wall. I decided to drill them in a manner that would cause the vortex to swirl around in a clockwise direction when viewed from the cold end of the tube. I did that because I used a 3/8" bolt as the 'Cone Valve' and it has a right hand thread. This way the hot air swirling around against the inner wall of the tube can easily 'unscrew' out the bolt thread.
 
One inlet jet hole drilled tangent to the I.D. of the vortex tube
Two inlet jet holes with wire inserted to show relationship / direction

As you can see from the above pictures I drilled two holes and they are on opposite sides of the tube. These are both drilled in the manifold groove so air can get into them and they are at a very slight angle toward the hot end of the tube. The angle is to help get the air moving away from the cold end. In the literature about 5° of angle is optimum but I just eyeballed it because being that precise with a small drill in a plastic tube isn't easy.
  
After getting the holes drilled in the tube I drilled a 0.54" hole in a 1 inch square block of PVC. This hole is sized so the tube in the above picture will slide in snugly. I then drilled and tapped a 1/8-NPT hole in the 1" block at 90° to the first hole for a pipe fitting. Check out the picture below!
 
Tapping a 1/8-NPT hole at a right angle to the 0.54" hole

In the above picture you are looking right down the 0.54" hole that the 1/4" PVC tube will be shoved into and glued. When I put the tube into this hole I centered the manifold groove right under the 1/8-NPT hole. That way when the air enters through the pipe fitting it can pass through the space formed by the groove and get to the inlet jets. I oriented the jets to be 90° to the inlet pipe fitting to help get an even flow in each jet, so in the above picture the jets would be horizontal.
 
After gluing the 1/4" tube into the 1" PVC block I installed a pipe fitting and a thermocouple to measure the inlet air temperature. The last step was to grind down the 3/8" bolt to make the cone valve.
  
My homemade Vortex Cooling Tube

Here is a picture of the finished tube. You can see the air inlet area in the lower right of the picture with the 1" square PVC block and air fittings. / thermocouple. Sticking out the cold end of the tube in the lower right is two pieces of white colored tube. Those white tubes make up the Cold Plate and are nothing more than a 1"4 I.D. piece of Kynar tubing inserted into a 3/8" O.D. silicon tube then both pushed into the PVC tube. Confusing isn't it? Refer way back to the construction diagram near the top of this post and it will make more sense. Also watch the exciting video at the end of this post!!
  
The last step I mentioned above was to grind down the 3/8" bolt to make the cone valve. I did this by cutting the head off the bolt and chucking it in my drill press with the threads sticking out. Once I got it spinning in the drill press I held a file against it and shaped it into a bullet shaped point that is about 0.2" on the end.
  

Vortex tube Cone Valve made from a 3/8" bolt
 
As you can see I mounted the bolt on a bent piece of aluminum plate to support it. I did this because I wanted to be able to adjust the bolt in and out of the tube. The adjustment was intended to vary the amount of hot air that was coming out to control the temperature. This did allow me to adjust the temperature and I found that the hottest (and coldest) temperature was with the bolt shoved all the way in the tube. Initially I had a small piece of the 1" PVC block with a hole in it to support the PVC tube while the bolt was being adjusted but I got interesting results with that set up. Check out the picture below:
 
Thermal image of my Vortex tube with the 1" block support
 
Pretty neat picture isn't it? It appears that the little piece of PVC support at the end of the tube is acting like a heat sink and drawing away some of the energy. I expect that if I let the tube run awhile the PVC support will reach  equilibrium with the tube temperature but even then it's dissipating some of the heat. This is why a plastic tube works better than a metal one and insulating a plastic tube will probably work even better.
  
After that first run I decided that I didn't need to adjust the bolt in and out and therefore didn't need the plastic support. I mounted the entire tube to a aluminum plate with the bolt inserted into the tube acting as the support for the tube. With that setup I got the best results.
 
Thermal image of the Vortex tube without support
 
Below is a video of the construction and testing of my Ranque-Hilsch Vortex Cooling Tube. If there is anything about this experiment that isn't clear please leave a comment on the blog or send me an email at ottobelden@yahoo.com and I'll be happy to help. Just like the other tubes I built this one was a lot of fun to make but even more fun because it worked so well!

25 comments:

  1. Otto,

    Your video is great, pics and comments are all right and explain how it is made very clearly. Thank you, from everbody who is trying to build a tube, whatever their reason is. I highly recommand to those like me to check out all the documents Otto have published, it turned out to be very useful !

    Thank you a lot again !

    Theo (French guy, please forget for any English mistakes)

    ReplyDelete
  2. hey plz can u tell me how much power we want in the compressor ?? it is very nice but we want high power compressor..so how much??

    ReplyDelete
  3. ah and can you tell me about a gas dynamics project plz..thanks

    ReplyDelete
  4. Sted,
    Thanks for checking out my blog!
    You have to know how much airflow your tube will require and size the compressor appropriately. If you have a tube like the one I built the compressor needs to be able to maintain 80psi for as long as your vortex tube is in operation. I would suggest you start by looking at the flow / pressure requirements of commercially available vortex tubes as a place to start.

    What sort of gas dynamics project are you interested in?
    - Otto

    ReplyDelete
  5. thanks for replying....another question:give me an advice about which experiment is better..?especially in choosing the dimentions of the tube..??!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Sted,
    The tube that I built (above) had the best performance of all the tubes that I have built. My advice is to make the tube on the smaller side as that will require less airflow and a smaller compressor. My first post about vortex tubes has 'rule of thumb' ratios of dimensions for length, orifice size etc. Do you have tubes and parts handy or are you going to go and buy all the peices?

    ReplyDelete
  7. No i am going to buy the pieces, because of this i am asking about dimensions and compressor. thank for your help

    ReplyDelete
  8. Sted,
    The above tube dimensions and parts are what I recommend based on my experiments, it's the best performing tube that I have built. I had to run it at my employer because my home compressor couldn't deliver the air flow at a high enough pressure to get good results. Be careful if you decide to build a tube. Compressed air can be dangerous and safety equipment is a must.
    - Otto

    ReplyDelete
  9. hello again,,,my question now is about the two holes in the tube..they must be drilled tangent to the tube or with a specific angle??

    ReplyDelete
  10. Sted,
    Tangent to the hole as best that you can make them. There is some literature that says that in addition to tangent a slight 1-5 deg angle toward the hot end helps too but I have not noticed that doing much. It makes it a lot harder to drill the holes as well.
    make them tangent and you should be OK. Be sure to wear safety stuff like eye protection etc... if the holes or the tube get plugged pressure can build up fast. A water trap in your air line is a good idea too.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Do you think a pancake compressor will supply enough air for a small project?

    ReplyDelete
  12. Bill,

    It depends on the airflow that your compressor can maintain. I have a Porter-Cable C2150 that is barley able to keep up with the smallest vortex tube that I have build (the one in this post). If I let the compressor fill the tank then run the tube it will drain the tank and the compressor can't keep up. For a short time the vortex tube works but to get the above results I had to take it into work and use the big compressor there.
    I checked out your blog! Lots of cool stuff there! If you build a vortex tube or have any questions email me, I'd be happy to help!

    - Otto

    ReplyDelete
  13. sir where did u get the accesories

    ReplyDelete
  14. Otto
    I need 2 calculate the refrigeration effect (kw)
    produced by a vortex tube with inlet air pressure of 2.5 bar and with a inflow rate of 4000 lpm..
    Also the temperature of inlet air is around 60 deg.
    Plz help

    ReplyDelete
  15. Anonymous,

    Everything you see in the construction (accessories) I either built from scratch or I found laying around in my garage. The thermal camera I borrowed from my employer.
    It would be difficult to calculate the refrigeration effect without knowing more about the tube itself. How many inlet jets, the thermal conductivity of the tube material etc... it would be a rough calculation only. 4000 lpm at 2.5 bar?? Is that right?
    Maybe with more info I can help you...

    - Otto

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hi, how did u calculate ratio betwen lenght and inner diametar, and orifice diameter, and cold side lenght :)
    Your drawing and table are values not the same ?
    At drawing inner diameter of orifice is 0.125, and in the table 0.25, or did i get it wrong.
    And one more question, i have tube of inner diameter 1/2", how long should be cold and hot end, and orifice diameter.
    Thnx !

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Miran,

      Thanks for checking out my blog! Below is a link to a post that I wrote that should answer your questions. Put some guidelines there that should help you figure it out based on the ID of the tube that you have.

      http://ottobelden.blogspot.com/2011/06/homemade-ranque-hilsch-vortex-cooling.html

      If you have any other questions after reading that post please let me know!

      - Otto

      Delete
  17. This would be a great way to super-charge a Sterling engine!

    ReplyDelete
  18. Hello Otto,
    I recently came across your vids at YT and am very intrigued with the idea of a homemade vortex cooling tube. I often work in hot confined spaces and have access to lots of compressed air so have considered purchasing a cooling tube tube but I'm a bit frugal and also like to tinker. Is it possible to eliminate the hot side completely and have you found a way to lower the noise factor?
    Thanks so much for all of your efforts in posting this info.
    Gene

    ReplyDelete
  19. Replies
    1. Степа Дятковский,

      I used a Fluke Thermal camera:
      http://www.fluke.com/fluke/usen/products/CategoryTI
      I don't know of any easy or economical way of making thermal images other than using a thermal camera. If you know of one please let me know!

      Otto

      Delete
  20. How did you got thermal images? In laboratory? Or it is possible to by some cam with "thermal-vision" ?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Степа Дятковский,

      I used a Fluke Thermal camera:
      http://www.fluke.com/fluke/usen/products/CategoryTI
      I don't know of any easy or economical way of making thermal images other than using a thermal camera. If you know of one please let me know!

      Otto

      Delete